Worst Premier League Managers: Ranking the Bottom of the Table
Since the Premier League’s inception in 1992, over 200 permanent managers have taken charge of various clubs. Among these, Chelsea and Tottenham have had the highest number of permanent managers, each with 28. The performance of these managers has varied widely, exacerbated by factors such as team position at takeover, financial circumstances, and other challenging elements tom ince. Despite being deemed the world’s best league, the Premier League brings immense pressure to its managers, who are consistently under scrutiny.
Some highly-rated managers have failed to meet the lofty expectations upon entering the league, resulting in career setbacks. The cutthroat nature of football has claimed many managerial careers in the Premier League. With frequent managerial sackings, the pressure to perform is ever-present. This analysis ranks the seven worst managers who led their teams for 25 or more games in the Premier League based on the following criteria:
- Points Per Game: The total points gathered during the manager’s tenure.
- Relegations: The ultimate outcome of their managerial period in the Premier League.
- Impact: The effect their leadership had on the club’s future and any subsequent returns to the top tier.
Managers noted for fewer than 25 Premier League games, such as Frank De Boer at Crystal Palace, are excluded from this list, which focuses on full-time managers for consistent comparison.
Ranking of the Seven Worst Managers
| Rank | Manager | Club | Years Active | Points Per Game |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Daniel Farke | Norwich City | 2019/20, 2021 | 0.53 |
| 2 | Vincent Kompany | Burnley | 2023/24 | 0.63 |
| 3 | Rob Edwards | Luton Town | 2023/24 | 0 palworld.68 |
| 4 | John Gorman | Swindon Town | 1993/94 | 0.71 |
| 5 | Aidy Boothroyd | Watford | 2006/07 | 0.74 |
| 6 | Scott Parker | Fulham, AFC Bournemouth | 2018/19, 2020/21, 2022 | 0.77 |
| 7 | Mick McCarthy | Sunderland, Wolves | 2005/06, 2009-2012 | 0.79 |
Manager Profiles
Mick McCarthy – Sunderland & Wolves
Having achieved success in the Championship with two titles, Mick McCarthy struggled in the Premier League, first with Sunderland in the 2005/06 season, which ended in relegation. He later managed to keep Wolves afloat for two seasons but ultimately was sacked due to poor performance.
Premier League Record: 138 Matches, 27 Wins, 109 Points, Points Per Game: 0.79
Scott Parker – Fulham & Bournemouth
Parker faced challenges in his time at Fulham, leading them to relegation twice despite winning promotion after his initial tenure. His stint at Bournemouth was abruptly cut short after a heavy defeat.
Premier League Record: 52 Matches, 9 Wins, 40 Points, Points Per Game: 0.77
Aidy Boothroyd – Watford
Boothroyd led Watford to the Premier League but managed only one disappointing season resulting in relegation. He later found success with England’s U21 setup.
Premier League Stats: 38 Matches, 5 Wins, 28 Points, Points Per Game: 0.74
John Gorman – Swindon
Taking charge after Hoddle’s departure, Gorman’s time with Swindon was plagued by a lack of resources, finishing at the bottom of the table after a dismal performance.
Premier League Stats: 42 Matches, 5 Wins, 30 Points, Points Per Game: 0. harrogate town vs liverpool u-2171
Rob Edwards – Luton
Edwards guided Luton to their first Premier League appearance in over three decades but could not secure their place in the league, facing relegation on the final day.
Premier League Stats: 38 Matches, 6 Wins, 26 Points, Points Per Game: 0.68
Vincent Kompany – Burnley
After leading Burnley to a Championship title, Kompany struggled in the Premier League, resulting in relegation. However, he quickly transitioned to a top managerial role in Germany.
Premier League Stats: 38 Matches, 5 Wins, 24 Points, Points Per Game: 0.63
Daniel Farke – Norwich
Farke’s tenure at Norwich was marked by two consecutive relegations burton vs notts county. Despite a record-setting Championship title in 2018/19, he could not sustain success in the Premier League.
Premier League Stats: 49 Matches, 6 Wins, 26 Points, Points Per Game: 0. rukayat gawat oyefeso53
All stats are sourced from TransferMarkt. Which of these managers do you think had the most potential to succeed in the Premier League?
Premier League, Managers, Football History, Sports Analysis, Relegation
